Among roofing materials, both stone coated roofing tiles and resin roofing tiles are commonly used types, and each has its own characteristics. But which one can better meet your needs? Below, we will conduct a comprehensive analysis of the two to help you make a wise choice.
1.Durability
Stone coated roofing tiles use aluminized zinc steel plates as the base plates, and this material endows them with outstanding corrosion resistance. Whether facing the erosion of acid rain, the test of a humid environment, or the invasion of high-salt air in coastal areas, stone coated roofing tiles can handle them with ease. Their service life can be as long as 50 years or even longer. For example, on the buildings of some seaside resorts, stone coated roofing tiles have withstood the baptism of sea breezes and waves for many years and still remain in good condition, providing solid and reliable roofing protection for the buildings.
Although resin roofing tiles have a certain degree of weather resistance, they are prone to problems such as aging, discoloration, and embrittlement under the long-term influence of ultraviolet radiation, temperature changes, and chemical substance erosion. Generally speaking, the service life of resin roofing tiles is about 15 to 20 years, which is relatively short. More frequent inspections and maintenance are needed to ensure the integrity and functionality of the roof.
2.Aesthetics
The surface of stone coated roofing tiles is covered with colored sand sintered at high temperatures. This not only gives them a rich variety of color options, ranging from bright red, blue to calm gray and black, but also creates a unique granular texture that can mimic the effects of natural slate, terra-cotta tiles, and so on, adding an elegant and noble temperament to the buildings. Whether it is the magnificence of European classical architecture or the fashion of modern minimalist architecture, stone coated roofing tiles can be perfectly adapted to show the unique charm of the buildings.
Resin roofing tiles are famous for their simple and fresh appearance. Their colors are relatively soft and elegant, and they usually present a smooth surface texture. They are suitable for some buildings that pursue a simple or pastoral style, such as rural villas and small residential houses, and can create a warm and natural atmosphere. However, compared with stone coated roofing tiles, resin roofing tiles are slightly lacking in the richness of color and texture.
3.Installation Convenience and Cost
Stone coated roofing tiles are lightweight, which greatly reduces the load-bearing pressure on the roof and makes the transportation and installation processes easier and more convenient. Their installation methods mainly combine snapping and nailing, and the operation is relatively simple. Skilled workers can complete the laying of a large area in a short time, thus effectively reducing labor costs. Although the initial purchase cost of stone coated roofing tiles is relatively high, their long service life and low maintenance cost give them certain advantages in terms of the comprehensive cost over the entire usage cycle.
Resin roofing tiles also have the characteristic of being convenient to install. They are lightweight, easy to cut and splice, and do not require special installation tools or complicated construction techniques. Ordinary workers can handle the installation. The initial price of resin roofing tiles is relatively affordable, which is attractive for some projects with limited budgets. However, due to their short service life, they need to be regularly maintained and replaced. In the long run, the accumulated costs may not be low.
4.Environmental Protection Characteristics
Both the base plates and colored sand of stone coated roofing tiles can be recycled and reused. During the production process, their energy consumption and pollutant emissions are relatively low, meeting the requirements of modern society for green and environmentally friendly building materials. From the perspective of resource utilization, stone coated roofing tiles have high sustainability and can effectively reduce the impact on the environment.
The production of resin roofing tiles involves some chemically synthesized materials. Although they cause relatively little direct pollution to the environment during use, the disposal after being discarded is relatively complicated, and the difficulty of recycling and reuse is relatively high, so their environmental protection performance is somewhat limited.
5.Fire Resistance
Stone coated roofing tiles have good fire resistance and belong to Class A non-combustible materials. In the event of a fire, they can effectively prevent the spread of the fire, providing a powerful guarantee for the safety of buildings and people. This characteristic makes stone coated roofing tiles widely used in some places with high fire protection requirements, such as factories, warehouses, and public buildings.
The fire resistance of resin roofing tiles is relatively weak. Generally, they are Class B combustible materials and are prone to burning and producing harmful gases under high-temperature environments, which restricts their use in some special places to a certain extent.
Based on the comprehensive comparison in all the above aspects, stone coated roofing tiles have relatively obvious advantages in terms of durability, aesthetics, environmental protection characteristics, and fire resistance. Although the initial cost is relatively high, from the perspective of long-term use and comprehensive benefits, they are a higher-quality choice for roofing materials. Of course, resin roofing tiles also have their applicability in certain specific scenarios and when budgets are limited. As a professional provider of roofing solutions, SKW is committed to providing global customers with high-quality stone coated roofing tile products and professional roofing solutions, enabling your buildings to have excellent roofing quality and show unique charm.